Scarboroughs Restaurant & Tavern: A Taste of American Comfort Food

Worth finding out where this little gem is hiding off Rt. 7. Prices are reasonable. I love the atmosphere. Service was wonderful. Will definitely go back.

1st time here on a very rainy night! Olivia was a great server. Coconut shrimp as an appetizer, excellent. If I see ahi tuna on the menu, you can bet I will order it. I had 3 options! How to decide? I went w Mango salsa blackened ahi tuna....delicious. enough for my lunch tomorrow! Just the right amount of heat, great cream sauce, chunks of mango. Excellent! My hubby got the crab cake blt and fries. Fries were seasoned to perfection. Crab cake blt....delicious! Wolf Hollow amber.....what a perfect Thursday night out! If you haven't been here before, you must check it out! Patio looks great for the warmer months!

8-24-25. The 3 of us had lunch, all trying something different. We thoroughly enjoyed our dining experience. They were quite busy. Great to see. I highly recommend. I went with the Meatloaf with green beans + mashed potatoes.

We had a large party and everything turned out beautifully. Our waitress was awesome. The food was served hot and delicious. No complaints from our group. Nice evening! Thank you.

All I have to say is "WOW!!" I met up with a friend I had not seen in a while who suggested this place, I am so sorry I never heard of it before because it was so fantastic! We started off with the spinach and artichoke dip that was so flavorful and amazing! My friend got the French onion, which she has gotten before and stated it's the best French onion soup she has ever had around here. I was torn between everything on their menu because, I wanted everything. Our waiter help me choose between the two that I was stuck on and stated the steak salad was one of their top sellers, so I went with that, and im so happy I did! The steak was cooked to perfection! Every bite so flavorful and amazing! The Italian dressing was so flavorful, the spices from the nuts mixed so beautifully with the steak, the creaminess from the blue cheese and the tart from the craisins 10 out of 10!! I have already told 5 people we have to go there with how amazing this steak salad was, and I will be telling many more. I want to add, the music was amazing some of my favorites playing, the atmosphere was so rustic snd cozy. I absolutely can not wait to go back and try more! So happy to have found this place!

Great spot. I had that Blackened Cajun Salmon Salad and it was great. It's so easy to dry out a piece of salmon. It was perfect with a great crust. All the veggies were fresh. Great service too. Would recommend anyone check it out.

Found this cute spot while we were in town for our Cooperstown visit. The burgers were good. The waitress was really sweet and attentive. She gave us enough to time to get settled in and offered recommendations which we took and were happy. The kids got the kids burger. I got the Buffalo burger and my husband got the beef on weck.

Amazing!!! The atmosphere was lovely, calming, cozy. Felt very "at home" type vibes. The food was ALL delightful & delicious. Even the house salad (with their house made cucumber Avocado ranch dressing. My goodness). My group loved every single meal they got! The Service was also amazing. Our waitress Alex was such a delight. Really great vibe, personality and gave us tons of attention! The desserts were all absolutely perfect! Even the drinks were amazing. We will most absolutely be back in the future!!!